Why everyone from Joe Manchin to the DSA is happy with Tim Walz

• Kamala Harris seemingly pleased every major faction on the left by picking Gov. Tim Walz as her VP.
• Progressives are happy. Moderates are happy. Even the DSA is taking a victory lap.
• That's because Walz has taken on the identity of both a moderate and a progressive as a politician.

Hours after Vice President Kamala Harris selected Gov. Tim Walz as her running mate, Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez went on Instagram Live.

The New York congresswoman, a progressive stalwart who identifies as a Democratic socialist, marveled at the fact that both her and Sen. Joe Manchin of West Virginia — the Democrat-turned-independent who's long frustrated progressive priorities — were on the same page about the Minnesota governor.

"That really is no small feat. It's really kind of nuts," Ocasio-Cortez said. "I am trying to think about the last time Senator Manchin and I, respectfully, were on the same side of an issue."

Manchin, for his part, said in a statement that Walz will "bring normality back to the most chaotic political environment that most of us have ever seen."

By one measure, Waltz has wider appeal among the Democratic Party's various factions than Harris: Manchin has declined to endorse the vice president herself, saying that she's "too far to the left."

The secret to Walz's broad appeal within the Democratic Party may be his dual identity: 12 years as a moderate in the House, then more than five years as a progressive governor.

From moderate House member to progressive governor

A former public school teacher, Walz was elected to Congress during the Democratic wave of 2006, unseating a Republican incumbent in a largely rural, conservative-leaning district.

For most of his time in Congress, he had an "A" rating from the National Rifle Association (NRA). Between 2015 and 2017, he was ranked the seventh most bipartisan member of the House, a metric based on co-sponsoring bills with lawmakers in the opposite party.

He later blasted the NRA after the Parkland shooting in 2018 and donated the money he'd received from the group to charity.

As governor, he signed a raft of progressive legislation, including a universal school lunch program, mandating paid family and medical leave, expanding the child tax credit, legalizing cannabis, and increasing funding for public schools.

Those accomplishments have earned Walz the admiration of progressives, including those in Congress who would like to see those policies enacted at the federal level.

Some of this is probably about vibes, too

Meanwhile, the Democratic Socialists of America took a victory lap over Walz's selection, saying it had "shown the world that DSA and our allies on the left are a force that cannot be ignored."

That's because many on the left did not want Harris to choose Gov. Josh Shapiro of Pennsylvania, who had drawn scrutiny for his support for Israel and his comments comparing some pro-Palestinian protestors to the Ku Klux Klan.

Yet, on policy, Walz isn't all that different from Shapiro. And it's unclear that pro-Palestinian activists' concerns played a role in Harris' selection of Walz. Some reporting has suggested that it had more to do with the Pennsylvania governor's own political ambitions.

It may simply be that Walz's identity — a white man of relatively modest means with a military background who grew up in rural Nebraska — allows everyone to see something different in the new VP candidate.

If you're Joe Manchin or a Democrat in a swing district, you probably like that Walz isn't from the coasts, is still a hunter, and has conservative family members. If you're a progressive, the Minnesota governor represents a throwback to the Democratic Party's populist roots.

"I think what we are seeing, slowly but surely, is a return to the Democratic Party's actual roots of a populist working class party," Ocasio-Cortez said on Instagram Live.